[Verse] Neon hums above the midnight glow, Two cups of coffee, cold and low. You trace the cracks in the Formica top, I’m countin’ heartaches that never stop. [Pre-Chorus] Your eyes say you’ve been runnin’ too long, Mine just sing a lonesome song. [Chorus] Pie and pain, we’re sippin’ on the same blues, Trading loss like lovers do. In this late-night diner, under flicker and flame, Two strangers, one story, one name— Pie and pain. [Verse] Dusty boots on the linoleum floor, Secrets spill from the jukebox door. You tell me ‘bout the love you lost, I’m lettin’ go of what I tossed. [Pre-Chorus] Your voice holds a smoky refrain, My heart beats in your slow, sweet pain. [Chorus] Pie and pain, we’re sippin’ on the same blues, Trading loss like lovers do. In this late-night diner, under flicker and flame, Two strangers, one story, one name— Pie and pain. [Bridge] A slice of sorrow, a dash of hope, In the quiet night, we both cope. Hands barely touch but souls collide, In the smoky dim where heartache hides. [Chorus] Pie and pain, we’re sippin’ on the same blues, Trading loss like lovers do. In this late-night diner, under flicker and flame, Two strangers, one story, one name— Pie and pain. [Outro] Two strangers, one story, one name— Pie and pain.